Homework 11 Solutions

Solution Files

You can find the solutions in the hw11.sql file.

To complete this homework assignment, you will need to use SQLite version 3.8.3 or greater. See Lab 12 for setup and usage instructions.

To check your progress, you can run sqlite3 directly by running:

sqlite3 --init hw11.sql

You should also check your work using ok:

python3 ok

Dog Data

In each question below, you will define a new table based on the following tables.

  SELECT "abraham" AS parent, "barack" AS child UNION
  SELECT "abraham"          , "clinton"         UNION
  SELECT "delano"           , "herbert"         UNION
  SELECT "fillmore"         , "abraham"         UNION
  SELECT "fillmore"         , "delano"          UNION
  SELECT "fillmore"         , "grover"          UNION
  SELECT "eisenhower"       , "fillmore";

  SELECT "abraham" AS name, "long" AS fur, 26 AS height UNION
  SELECT "barack"         , "short"      , 52           UNION
  SELECT "clinton"        , "long"       , 47           UNION
  SELECT "delano"         , "long"       , 46           UNION
  SELECT "eisenhower"     , "short"      , 35           UNION
  SELECT "fillmore"       , "curly"      , 32           UNION
  SELECT "grover"         , "short"      , 28           UNION
  SELECT "herbert"        , "curly"      , 31;

  SELECT "toy" AS size, 24 AS min, 28 AS max UNION
  SELECT "mini"       , 28       , 35        UNION
  SELECT "medium"     , 35       , 45        UNION
  SELECT "standard"   , 45       , 60;

Your tables should still perform correctly even if the values in these tables change. For example, if you are asked to list all dogs with a name that starts with h, you should write:

SELECT name FROM dogs WHERE "h" <= name AND name < "i";

Instead of assuming that the dogs table has only the data above and writing

SELECT "herbert";

The former query would still be correct if the name grover were changed to hoover or a row was added with the name harry.

Q1: Size of Dogs

The Fédération Cynologique Internationale classifies a standard poodle as over 45 cm and up to 60 cm. The sizes table describes this and other such classifications, where a dog must be over the min and less than or equal to the max in height to qualify as a size.

Create a size_of_dogs table with two columns, one for each dog's name and another for its size.

-- The size of each dog
CREATE TABLE size_of_dogs AS
SELECT name, size FROM dogs, sizes WHERE height > min AND height <= max;

The output should look like the following:

sqlite> select * from size_of_dogs;

Use Ok to test your code:

python3 ok -q size_of_dogs

We know that at a minimum, we need information from both the dogs and sizes table. Finally, we filter and keep only the rows that make sense: a size that corresponds to the size of the dog we're currently considering.

Q2: By Parent Height

Create a table by_parent_height that has a column of the names of all dogs that have a parent, ordered by the height of the parent from tallest parent to shortest parent.
-- All dogs with parents ordered by decreasing height of their parent
CREATE TABLE by_parent_height AS
SELECT child FROM parents, dogs WHERE name = parent ORDER BY -height;

For example, fillmore has a parent (eisenhower) with height 35, and so should appear before grover who has a parent (fillmore) with height 32. The names of dogs with parents of the same height should appear together in any order. For example, barack and clinton should both appear at the end, but either one can come before the other.

sqlite> select * from by_parent_height;

Use Ok to test your code:

python3 ok -q by_parent_height

We need information from both the parents and the dogs table. This time, the only rows that make sense are the ones where a child is matched up with their parent. Finally, we order the result by descending height.

Q3: Sentences

There are two pairs of siblings that have the same size. Create a table that contains a row with a string for each of these pairs. Each string should be a sentence describing the siblings by their size.
-- Filling out this helper table is optional
SELECT a.child AS first, b.child AS second FROM parents AS a, parents AS b WHERE a.parent = b.parent AND a.child < b.child;
-- Sentences about siblings that are the same size CREATE TABLE sentences AS
SELECT first || " and " || second || " are " || a.size || " siblings" FROM siblings, size_of_dogs AS a, size_of_dogs AS b WHERE a.size = b.size AND a.name = first AND b.name = second;

Each sibling pair should appear only once in the output, and siblings should be listed in alphabetical order (e.g. "barack and clinton..." instead of "clinton and barack..."), as follows:

sqlite> select * from sentences;
abraham and grover are toy siblings
barack and clinton are standard siblings

Hint: First, create a helper table containing each pair of siblings. This will make comparing the sizes of siblings when constructing the main table easier.

Use Ok to test your code:

python3 ok -q sentences

Roughly speaking, there are two tasks we need to solve here:

Figure out which dogs are siblings

A sibling is someone you share a parent with. This will probably involve the parents table.

It might be tempting to join this with dogs, but there isn't any extra information provided by a dogs table that we need at this time. Furthermore, we still need information on sibling for a given dog, since the parents table just associates each dog to a parent.

The next step, therefore, is to match all children to all other children by joining the parents table to itself. The only rows here that make sense are the rows that represent sibling relationships since they share the same parent.

Remember that we want to avoid duplicates! If dog A and B are siblings, we don't want both A/B and B/A to appear in the final result. We also definitely don't want A/A to be a sibling pair. Enforcing ordering on the sibling names ensures that we don't have either issue.

Construct sentences based on sibling information

After determining the siblings, constructing the sentences just requires us to get the size of each sibling. We could join on the dogs and sizes tables as we did in an earlier problem, but there's no need to redo that work. Instead, we'll reuse our size_of_dogs table to figure out the size of each sibling in each pair.

Q4: Stacks

Sufficiently sure-footed dogs can stand on either other's backs to form a stack (up to a point). We'll say that the total height of such a stack is the sum of the heights of the dogs.

Create a two-column table describing all stacks of up to four dogs at least 170 cm high. The first column should contain a comma-separated list of dogs in the stack, and the second column should contain the total height of the stack. Order the stacks in increasing order of total height.

-- Ways to stack 4 dogs to a height of at least 170, ordered by total height
CREATE TABLE stacks_helper(dogs, stack_height, last_height);

INSERT INTO stacks_helper SELECT name, height, height FROM dogs; INSERT INTO stacks_helper SELECT dogs || ", " || name, stack_height + height, height FROM stacks_helper, dogs WHERE height > last_height; INSERT INTO stacks_helper SELECT dogs || ", " || name, stack_height + height, height FROM stacks_helper, dogs WHERE height > last_height; INSERT INTO stacks_helper SELECT dogs || ", " || name, stack_height + height, height FROM stacks_helper, dogs WHERE height > last_height;
SELECT dogs, stack_height FROM stacks_helper WHERE stack_height >= 170 ORDER BY stack_height;

A valid stack of dogs includes each dog only once, and the dogs should be listed in increasing order of height within the stack. You may assume that no two dogs have the same height.

sqlite> select * from stacks;
abraham, delano, clinton, barack|171
grover, delano, clinton, barack|173
herbert, delano, clinton, barack|176
fillmore, delano, clinton, barack|177
eisenhower, delano, clinton, barack|180

You should use the provided helper table stacks_helper. It has 3 columns: (1) dogs - a stack of dogs as a comma separated list of dog names, (2) stack_height - the height of the stack, and (3) last_height - the height of the last dog added to the stack (in order to ensure we have the right order in the stack).

First, fill this table up by doing the following:

  1. Use an INSERT INTO to add stacks of just one dog into stacks_helper. You can use this syntax to insert rows from a table called t1 into a table called t2:

    INSERT INTO t2 SELECT [expression] FROM t1 ...;

    For example:

    sqlite> CREATE TABLE t1 AS
    ...>        SELECT 1 as a, 2 as b;
    sqlite> CREATE TABLE t2(c, d);
    sqlite> INSERT INTO t2 SELECT a, b FROM t1;
    sqlite> SELECT * FROM t2;
  2. Now, use the stacks of one dog to insert stacks of two dogs. It's possible to INSERT INTO a table rows selected from that same table. For example,

    sqlite> CREATE TABLE ints AS
       ...>   SELECT 1 AS n UNION
       ...>   SELECT 2      UNION
       ...>   SELECT 3;
    sqlite> INSERT INTO ints(n) SELECT n+3 FROM ints;
    sqlite> SELECT * FROM ints;
  3. Repeat step 3 to create stacks of three dogs, then of four dogs.

Once you've built up to stacks of four dogs in your stacks_helper table, use it to fill in the stacks table!

Use Ok to test your code:

python3 ok -q stacks

In the solution, we follow the recommended procedure outlined in the problem above.

Here's some details to think about:

  • Each iteration, we will generate the stack with n + 1 dogs, but we'll also regenerate all the previous stacks! For example, the stacks of size 1 are still around to generate the stacks of size 2. As such there are many duplicate rows of stack size 1, 2, and 3 in our stack_helper.
  • This turns out not to be an issue: we got lucky since there weren't any stacks of size less than 4 that were tall enough. But even if there were, we could use DISTINCT to remove duplicate rows.
  • Is there a way we could be more space efficient? Think about how we could generate new rows without keeping around all the previous ones.

Once we have everything in our stack_helper table, we just keep the rows from it that correspond to the tallest stacks. We also no longer need the last_height column.